Project Runway Thoughts
Jan. 2nd, 2012 06:22 pm![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
iariaThe Finale
Kimberly: A lot of Kimberly's colour choices were a bit too bold for me. The blue especially didn't really work for me except in the dress. I loved the blue dress. Very pretty. The shiny blue top/skirt was nice except much too shiny. I was not a fan of the fabric. The pink dress was nice but I disliked the jacket and the rest of the pink in the collection was meh. I didn't like the pink skirt. It looked off. The ivory pants/top was lovely. The final black dress was okay. Her collection was actually one I liked more when I looked at pictures while writing this.
Josh: The opening purple dress was a remake of his orange one and I liked it though I preferred it in orange actually. I agree with Tim on the print his used; I'm not a fan. The green short look was horrible. The worst of the runway looks. I also hated the top which made the model's body look weird and the whole thing was so unflattering. The simple black dress was nice. I liked the first long black dress, especially from the front, and though the back looked much better seemingly randomly draped instead of as a tight jumpsuit I still didn't like it.
Viktor: I disliked all his sheer shirts and his sheer dress a lot but thought the mirrored shirts were interesting and his prints were great. The pink print pants shouldn't have worked for me but I actually kind of like them. They worked with the mirrored top and black jacket. The short dress and long dress in the same blue/black/white print were my favourites.
Anya: Her collection had a 'sameness' about it and while a collection should have cohesion clearly Anya's was a bit too much of 'more of the same', imo. There were a lot of deep plunging necklines which I wasn't very fond of. That said the first dress was nice. I liked the fabric. The brown dress was simple but nice. I liked both of her long black and white dresses. Individual her pieces didn't wow me but overall they had a breezy and easy feel to them that was nice.
- I like that Anya won because I like her and I've loved her designs consistently this season but I don't know that she had the strongest collection here in the finale. But then I don't know who I would have chosen other than her because none of the collections wowed me.
- I thought going in that Viktor would win but I agree with the judges that it felt like he had two collections happening. If he'd continued with the prints and dropped the sheer stuff it would have been so much better.
- On thing I definitely know is that Josh shouldn't have been in the final two. WTF? His collection was so ugly. This was definitely one time I was not on the same page as the judges.
Kimberly: A lot of Kimberly's colour choices were a bit too bold for me. The blue especially didn't really work for me except in the dress. I loved the blue dress. Very pretty. The shiny blue top/skirt was nice except much too shiny. I was not a fan of the fabric. The pink dress was nice but I disliked the jacket and the rest of the pink in the collection was meh. I didn't like the pink skirt. It looked off. The ivory pants/top was lovely. The final black dress was okay. Her collection was actually one I liked more when I looked at pictures while writing this.
Josh: The opening purple dress was a remake of his orange one and I liked it though I preferred it in orange actually. I agree with Tim on the print his used; I'm not a fan. The green short look was horrible. The worst of the runway looks. I also hated the top which made the model's body look weird and the whole thing was so unflattering. The simple black dress was nice. I liked the first long black dress, especially from the front, and though the back looked much better seemingly randomly draped instead of as a tight jumpsuit I still didn't like it.
Viktor: I disliked all his sheer shirts and his sheer dress a lot but thought the mirrored shirts were interesting and his prints were great. The pink print pants shouldn't have worked for me but I actually kind of like them. They worked with the mirrored top and black jacket. The short dress and long dress in the same blue/black/white print were my favourites.
Anya: Her collection had a 'sameness' about it and while a collection should have cohesion clearly Anya's was a bit too much of 'more of the same', imo. There were a lot of deep plunging necklines which I wasn't very fond of. That said the first dress was nice. I liked the fabric. The brown dress was simple but nice. I liked both of her long black and white dresses. Individual her pieces didn't wow me but overall they had a breezy and easy feel to them that was nice.
- I like that Anya won because I like her and I've loved her designs consistently this season but I don't know that she had the strongest collection here in the finale. But then I don't know who I would have chosen other than her because none of the collections wowed me.
- I thought going in that Viktor would win but I agree with the judges that it felt like he had two collections happening. If he'd continued with the prints and dropped the sheer stuff it would have been so much better.
- On thing I definitely know is that Josh shouldn't have been in the final two. WTF? His collection was so ugly. This was definitely one time I was not on the same page as the judges.
